Is it inappropriate for a student to attend their mentor's dissertation defense?












59















I'm an undergraduate student at a research one university. My former instructor and current research mentor is defending their dissertation soon. I asked if I could attend and they said they would be fine with it.



My primary interest in doing so is to see how the defense process works for when I attend graduate school. I am also just genuinely interested in supporting them since we both research the same material and they've been incredibly encouraging and helpful to me.



I know defenses are open to the public, but, in your opinion, would a student attending your defense add more stress or disrupt the process? I just want to make sure I'm not making anything more difficult for them or overstepping a boundary, even though they say they are totally okay with me attending.










share|improve this question









New contributor




Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
















  • 5





    A country tag might be appropriate. Some countries do not have public thesis defenses, for example, and in some places the defense happens in several parts with different assumptions about attendance.

    – Tommi Brander
    Apr 3 at 7:19











  • Discussions about the definition of professor as well as answers in comments have been moved to chat. Please read this FAQ before posting another comment.

    – Wrzlprmft
    2 days ago













  • Go! Four of my friends flew nearly 700 miles to attend my defense. I was really happy to see friendly faces in the room, and they took me out to a memorable dinner afterwards. (You don't need to do the dinner, though.)

    – Bob Brown
    2 days ago
















59















I'm an undergraduate student at a research one university. My former instructor and current research mentor is defending their dissertation soon. I asked if I could attend and they said they would be fine with it.



My primary interest in doing so is to see how the defense process works for when I attend graduate school. I am also just genuinely interested in supporting them since we both research the same material and they've been incredibly encouraging and helpful to me.



I know defenses are open to the public, but, in your opinion, would a student attending your defense add more stress or disrupt the process? I just want to make sure I'm not making anything more difficult for them or overstepping a boundary, even though they say they are totally okay with me attending.










share|improve this question









New contributor




Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
















  • 5





    A country tag might be appropriate. Some countries do not have public thesis defenses, for example, and in some places the defense happens in several parts with different assumptions about attendance.

    – Tommi Brander
    Apr 3 at 7:19











  • Discussions about the definition of professor as well as answers in comments have been moved to chat. Please read this FAQ before posting another comment.

    – Wrzlprmft
    2 days ago













  • Go! Four of my friends flew nearly 700 miles to attend my defense. I was really happy to see friendly faces in the room, and they took me out to a memorable dinner afterwards. (You don't need to do the dinner, though.)

    – Bob Brown
    2 days ago














59












59








59


5






I'm an undergraduate student at a research one university. My former instructor and current research mentor is defending their dissertation soon. I asked if I could attend and they said they would be fine with it.



My primary interest in doing so is to see how the defense process works for when I attend graduate school. I am also just genuinely interested in supporting them since we both research the same material and they've been incredibly encouraging and helpful to me.



I know defenses are open to the public, but, in your opinion, would a student attending your defense add more stress or disrupt the process? I just want to make sure I'm not making anything more difficult for them or overstepping a boundary, even though they say they are totally okay with me attending.










share|improve this question









New contributor




Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.












I'm an undergraduate student at a research one university. My former instructor and current research mentor is defending their dissertation soon. I asked if I could attend and they said they would be fine with it.



My primary interest in doing so is to see how the defense process works for when I attend graduate school. I am also just genuinely interested in supporting them since we both research the same material and they've been incredibly encouraging and helpful to me.



I know defenses are open to the public, but, in your opinion, would a student attending your defense add more stress or disrupt the process? I just want to make sure I'm not making anything more difficult for them or overstepping a boundary, even though they say they are totally okay with me attending.







thesis students defense






share|improve this question









New contributor




Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.











share|improve this question









New contributor




Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Apr 3 at 2:58









cag51

18.2k83869




18.2k83869






New contributor




Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









asked Apr 3 at 2:53









NicoleNicole

302123




302123




New contributor




Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.





New contributor





Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.






Nicole is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.








  • 5





    A country tag might be appropriate. Some countries do not have public thesis defenses, for example, and in some places the defense happens in several parts with different assumptions about attendance.

    – Tommi Brander
    Apr 3 at 7:19











  • Discussions about the definition of professor as well as answers in comments have been moved to chat. Please read this FAQ before posting another comment.

    – Wrzlprmft
    2 days ago













  • Go! Four of my friends flew nearly 700 miles to attend my defense. I was really happy to see friendly faces in the room, and they took me out to a memorable dinner afterwards. (You don't need to do the dinner, though.)

    – Bob Brown
    2 days ago














  • 5





    A country tag might be appropriate. Some countries do not have public thesis defenses, for example, and in some places the defense happens in several parts with different assumptions about attendance.

    – Tommi Brander
    Apr 3 at 7:19











  • Discussions about the definition of professor as well as answers in comments have been moved to chat. Please read this FAQ before posting another comment.

    – Wrzlprmft
    2 days ago













  • Go! Four of my friends flew nearly 700 miles to attend my defense. I was really happy to see friendly faces in the room, and they took me out to a memorable dinner afterwards. (You don't need to do the dinner, though.)

    – Bob Brown
    2 days ago








5




5





A country tag might be appropriate. Some countries do not have public thesis defenses, for example, and in some places the defense happens in several parts with different assumptions about attendance.

– Tommi Brander
Apr 3 at 7:19





A country tag might be appropriate. Some countries do not have public thesis defenses, for example, and in some places the defense happens in several parts with different assumptions about attendance.

– Tommi Brander
Apr 3 at 7:19













Discussions about the definition of professor as well as answers in comments have been moved to chat. Please read this FAQ before posting another comment.

– Wrzlprmft
2 days ago







Discussions about the definition of professor as well as answers in comments have been moved to chat. Please read this FAQ before posting another comment.

– Wrzlprmft
2 days ago















Go! Four of my friends flew nearly 700 miles to attend my defense. I was really happy to see friendly faces in the room, and they took me out to a memorable dinner afterwards. (You don't need to do the dinner, though.)

– Bob Brown
2 days ago





Go! Four of my friends flew nearly 700 miles to attend my defense. I was really happy to see friendly faces in the room, and they took me out to a memorable dinner afterwards. (You don't need to do the dinner, though.)

– Bob Brown
2 days ago










5 Answers
5






active

oldest

votes


















134














It's fine. As you say, these are open to the public, and it's common for family members, department members, and friends to attend. Since you perhaps are not "firmly" in any of these categories, asking whether it's okay to attend is probably a good idea -- but you've already done this and been given the green light. Enjoy.






share|improve this answer



















  • 69





    I would actually have been more offended if the student I was tutoring did not attend the defense.

    – Bernhard
    Apr 3 at 6:00






  • 24





    This answer really sums it up, the only thing I would add to it is that the OP even asked if it's ok to attend. At this point it would be almost inexcusable to not show up.

    – posdef
    Apr 3 at 7:32



















105














I think @cag51's answer ("it's fine") is actually a bit too mild. Please go if you can!



Attitudes towards thesis defenses seem to vary a bit from program to program. My PhD program had a pretty strong (but informal) expectation that people would attend defenses, especially if they a) worked together b) worked in the same sub-field, or c) were friendly. That expectation is weaker in my current department: students do go, but it's acceptable to skip defenses due to non-specific 'busyness' too.



On a more personal note, the final stages of grad school are often lonely and miserable, or at least it was for me. It was therefore incredibly touching to have people turn up for the defense: the room was packed with friends, family, collaborators, and even a few new people who were inexplicably interested in my work. To the extent that your presence triggers an emotion, I think it's much more likely to be gratitude and pride ("Awww, she came!") than stress or confusion ("What's she doing here?!").



Plus, there might be some free food afterward!






share|improve this answer





















  • 2





    Re: loneliness and stress.. What you say is on point, although how people react to that varies, to say the least. My gf didn't want me to attend her thesis, specifically saying that my presence there would stress her even more.. Re: free food - for us there is usually a reception with bubbles, food and beer... so that's always a plus :P

    – posdef
    Apr 3 at 7:31






  • 9





    Re: free food afterwards. It is quite common at my university to have a small snack and a drink right after the defense with your commitee and all the guests, and often you have even more snacks and drinks with your guests, after the commitee left. Essentially, after the defense is over you have a party of sorts.

    – Dohn Joe
    Apr 3 at 8:59






  • 1





    +1, and agree that it varies...perhaps I was too mild because we never ever had more than ~10 people show up to a defense, and for my defense, there was only the committee and one student (even I didn't show up! [was on the phone from thousands of miles away]). I can imagine such a situation being uncomfortable for an undergrad

    – cag51
    Apr 4 at 1:16






  • 5





    +1 for free food!

    – Jakub Konieczny
    Apr 4 at 9:01






  • 1





    Echoing praise for paragraph 3. That's how I felt about it. It helped quite a bit.

    – Randall
    Apr 5 at 1:16



















11














In the similar situations I know (habilitation kind of dissertations) it will be seen bizarre if you are not there, both on scientific as well as human relationship point of views.






share|improve this answer































    2














    This is a normal thing to do. I was in a similar position and will be attending my mentor's dissertation in May. It's nice to give back to someone who has helped you out a lot by supporting them during a very challenging experience. Just make sure he's okay with it. He will probably be very encouraged!






    share|improve this answer








    New contributor




    ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
    Check out our Code of Conduct.




























      1














      It's fine, I have walked into stressful defence-type lectures which one of my teachers was teaching. I don't mean to put the person off, but it's standard and you have to get used to it. When I first started teaching even though I was nervous I invited my friend to sit in on one of my lectures as it's something you have to get used to. Anyone can walk in there, you could be giving a stressful lecture one day and a family member you haven't seen for ages will randomly walk in and sit down to watch.






      share|improve this answer



















      • 5





        It's not about teaching

        – George M
        Apr 3 at 20:49






      • 2





        @GeorgeM : No, but it is a similar situation

        – MPW
        Apr 3 at 20:55






      • 8





        Not at all, but whatever..

        – George M
        Apr 3 at 20:56












      Your Answer








      StackExchange.ready(function() {
      var channelOptions = {
      tags: "".split(" "),
      id: "415"
      };
      initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

      StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
      // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
      if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
      StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
      createEditor();
      });
      }
      else {
      createEditor();
      }
      });

      function createEditor() {
      StackExchange.prepareEditor({
      heartbeatType: 'answer',
      autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
      convertImagesToLinks: true,
      noModals: true,
      showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
      reputationToPostImages: 10,
      bindNavPrevention: true,
      postfix: "",
      imageUploader: {
      brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
      contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
      allowUrls: true
      },
      noCode: true, onDemand: true,
      discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
      ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
      });


      }
      });






      Nicole is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.










      draft saved

      draft discarded


















      StackExchange.ready(
      function () {
      StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2facademia.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f127430%2fis-it-inappropriate-for-a-student-to-attend-their-mentors-dissertation-defense%23new-answer', 'question_page');
      }
      );

      Post as a guest















      Required, but never shown

























      5 Answers
      5






      active

      oldest

      votes








      5 Answers
      5






      active

      oldest

      votes









      active

      oldest

      votes






      active

      oldest

      votes









      134














      It's fine. As you say, these are open to the public, and it's common for family members, department members, and friends to attend. Since you perhaps are not "firmly" in any of these categories, asking whether it's okay to attend is probably a good idea -- but you've already done this and been given the green light. Enjoy.






      share|improve this answer



















      • 69





        I would actually have been more offended if the student I was tutoring did not attend the defense.

        – Bernhard
        Apr 3 at 6:00






      • 24





        This answer really sums it up, the only thing I would add to it is that the OP even asked if it's ok to attend. At this point it would be almost inexcusable to not show up.

        – posdef
        Apr 3 at 7:32
















      134














      It's fine. As you say, these are open to the public, and it's common for family members, department members, and friends to attend. Since you perhaps are not "firmly" in any of these categories, asking whether it's okay to attend is probably a good idea -- but you've already done this and been given the green light. Enjoy.






      share|improve this answer



















      • 69





        I would actually have been more offended if the student I was tutoring did not attend the defense.

        – Bernhard
        Apr 3 at 6:00






      • 24





        This answer really sums it up, the only thing I would add to it is that the OP even asked if it's ok to attend. At this point it would be almost inexcusable to not show up.

        – posdef
        Apr 3 at 7:32














      134












      134








      134







      It's fine. As you say, these are open to the public, and it's common for family members, department members, and friends to attend. Since you perhaps are not "firmly" in any of these categories, asking whether it's okay to attend is probably a good idea -- but you've already done this and been given the green light. Enjoy.






      share|improve this answer













      It's fine. As you say, these are open to the public, and it's common for family members, department members, and friends to attend. Since you perhaps are not "firmly" in any of these categories, asking whether it's okay to attend is probably a good idea -- but you've already done this and been given the green light. Enjoy.







      share|improve this answer












      share|improve this answer



      share|improve this answer










      answered Apr 3 at 3:02









      cag51cag51

      18.2k83869




      18.2k83869








      • 69





        I would actually have been more offended if the student I was tutoring did not attend the defense.

        – Bernhard
        Apr 3 at 6:00






      • 24





        This answer really sums it up, the only thing I would add to it is that the OP even asked if it's ok to attend. At this point it would be almost inexcusable to not show up.

        – posdef
        Apr 3 at 7:32














      • 69





        I would actually have been more offended if the student I was tutoring did not attend the defense.

        – Bernhard
        Apr 3 at 6:00






      • 24





        This answer really sums it up, the only thing I would add to it is that the OP even asked if it's ok to attend. At this point it would be almost inexcusable to not show up.

        – posdef
        Apr 3 at 7:32








      69




      69





      I would actually have been more offended if the student I was tutoring did not attend the defense.

      – Bernhard
      Apr 3 at 6:00





      I would actually have been more offended if the student I was tutoring did not attend the defense.

      – Bernhard
      Apr 3 at 6:00




      24




      24





      This answer really sums it up, the only thing I would add to it is that the OP even asked if it's ok to attend. At this point it would be almost inexcusable to not show up.

      – posdef
      Apr 3 at 7:32





      This answer really sums it up, the only thing I would add to it is that the OP even asked if it's ok to attend. At this point it would be almost inexcusable to not show up.

      – posdef
      Apr 3 at 7:32











      105














      I think @cag51's answer ("it's fine") is actually a bit too mild. Please go if you can!



      Attitudes towards thesis defenses seem to vary a bit from program to program. My PhD program had a pretty strong (but informal) expectation that people would attend defenses, especially if they a) worked together b) worked in the same sub-field, or c) were friendly. That expectation is weaker in my current department: students do go, but it's acceptable to skip defenses due to non-specific 'busyness' too.



      On a more personal note, the final stages of grad school are often lonely and miserable, or at least it was for me. It was therefore incredibly touching to have people turn up for the defense: the room was packed with friends, family, collaborators, and even a few new people who were inexplicably interested in my work. To the extent that your presence triggers an emotion, I think it's much more likely to be gratitude and pride ("Awww, she came!") than stress or confusion ("What's she doing here?!").



      Plus, there might be some free food afterward!






      share|improve this answer





















      • 2





        Re: loneliness and stress.. What you say is on point, although how people react to that varies, to say the least. My gf didn't want me to attend her thesis, specifically saying that my presence there would stress her even more.. Re: free food - for us there is usually a reception with bubbles, food and beer... so that's always a plus :P

        – posdef
        Apr 3 at 7:31






      • 9





        Re: free food afterwards. It is quite common at my university to have a small snack and a drink right after the defense with your commitee and all the guests, and often you have even more snacks and drinks with your guests, after the commitee left. Essentially, after the defense is over you have a party of sorts.

        – Dohn Joe
        Apr 3 at 8:59






      • 1





        +1, and agree that it varies...perhaps I was too mild because we never ever had more than ~10 people show up to a defense, and for my defense, there was only the committee and one student (even I didn't show up! [was on the phone from thousands of miles away]). I can imagine such a situation being uncomfortable for an undergrad

        – cag51
        Apr 4 at 1:16






      • 5





        +1 for free food!

        – Jakub Konieczny
        Apr 4 at 9:01






      • 1





        Echoing praise for paragraph 3. That's how I felt about it. It helped quite a bit.

        – Randall
        Apr 5 at 1:16
















      105














      I think @cag51's answer ("it's fine") is actually a bit too mild. Please go if you can!



      Attitudes towards thesis defenses seem to vary a bit from program to program. My PhD program had a pretty strong (but informal) expectation that people would attend defenses, especially if they a) worked together b) worked in the same sub-field, or c) were friendly. That expectation is weaker in my current department: students do go, but it's acceptable to skip defenses due to non-specific 'busyness' too.



      On a more personal note, the final stages of grad school are often lonely and miserable, or at least it was for me. It was therefore incredibly touching to have people turn up for the defense: the room was packed with friends, family, collaborators, and even a few new people who were inexplicably interested in my work. To the extent that your presence triggers an emotion, I think it's much more likely to be gratitude and pride ("Awww, she came!") than stress or confusion ("What's she doing here?!").



      Plus, there might be some free food afterward!






      share|improve this answer





















      • 2





        Re: loneliness and stress.. What you say is on point, although how people react to that varies, to say the least. My gf didn't want me to attend her thesis, specifically saying that my presence there would stress her even more.. Re: free food - for us there is usually a reception with bubbles, food and beer... so that's always a plus :P

        – posdef
        Apr 3 at 7:31






      • 9





        Re: free food afterwards. It is quite common at my university to have a small snack and a drink right after the defense with your commitee and all the guests, and often you have even more snacks and drinks with your guests, after the commitee left. Essentially, after the defense is over you have a party of sorts.

        – Dohn Joe
        Apr 3 at 8:59






      • 1





        +1, and agree that it varies...perhaps I was too mild because we never ever had more than ~10 people show up to a defense, and for my defense, there was only the committee and one student (even I didn't show up! [was on the phone from thousands of miles away]). I can imagine such a situation being uncomfortable for an undergrad

        – cag51
        Apr 4 at 1:16






      • 5





        +1 for free food!

        – Jakub Konieczny
        Apr 4 at 9:01






      • 1





        Echoing praise for paragraph 3. That's how I felt about it. It helped quite a bit.

        – Randall
        Apr 5 at 1:16














      105












      105








      105







      I think @cag51's answer ("it's fine") is actually a bit too mild. Please go if you can!



      Attitudes towards thesis defenses seem to vary a bit from program to program. My PhD program had a pretty strong (but informal) expectation that people would attend defenses, especially if they a) worked together b) worked in the same sub-field, or c) were friendly. That expectation is weaker in my current department: students do go, but it's acceptable to skip defenses due to non-specific 'busyness' too.



      On a more personal note, the final stages of grad school are often lonely and miserable, or at least it was for me. It was therefore incredibly touching to have people turn up for the defense: the room was packed with friends, family, collaborators, and even a few new people who were inexplicably interested in my work. To the extent that your presence triggers an emotion, I think it's much more likely to be gratitude and pride ("Awww, she came!") than stress or confusion ("What's she doing here?!").



      Plus, there might be some free food afterward!






      share|improve this answer















      I think @cag51's answer ("it's fine") is actually a bit too mild. Please go if you can!



      Attitudes towards thesis defenses seem to vary a bit from program to program. My PhD program had a pretty strong (but informal) expectation that people would attend defenses, especially if they a) worked together b) worked in the same sub-field, or c) were friendly. That expectation is weaker in my current department: students do go, but it's acceptable to skip defenses due to non-specific 'busyness' too.



      On a more personal note, the final stages of grad school are often lonely and miserable, or at least it was for me. It was therefore incredibly touching to have people turn up for the defense: the room was packed with friends, family, collaborators, and even a few new people who were inexplicably interested in my work. To the extent that your presence triggers an emotion, I think it's much more likely to be gratitude and pride ("Awww, she came!") than stress or confusion ("What's she doing here?!").



      Plus, there might be some free food afterward!







      share|improve this answer














      share|improve this answer



      share|improve this answer








      edited Apr 3 at 7:20

























      answered Apr 3 at 7:11









      MattMatt

      1,93811014




      1,93811014








      • 2





        Re: loneliness and stress.. What you say is on point, although how people react to that varies, to say the least. My gf didn't want me to attend her thesis, specifically saying that my presence there would stress her even more.. Re: free food - for us there is usually a reception with bubbles, food and beer... so that's always a plus :P

        – posdef
        Apr 3 at 7:31






      • 9





        Re: free food afterwards. It is quite common at my university to have a small snack and a drink right after the defense with your commitee and all the guests, and often you have even more snacks and drinks with your guests, after the commitee left. Essentially, after the defense is over you have a party of sorts.

        – Dohn Joe
        Apr 3 at 8:59






      • 1





        +1, and agree that it varies...perhaps I was too mild because we never ever had more than ~10 people show up to a defense, and for my defense, there was only the committee and one student (even I didn't show up! [was on the phone from thousands of miles away]). I can imagine such a situation being uncomfortable for an undergrad

        – cag51
        Apr 4 at 1:16






      • 5





        +1 for free food!

        – Jakub Konieczny
        Apr 4 at 9:01






      • 1





        Echoing praise for paragraph 3. That's how I felt about it. It helped quite a bit.

        – Randall
        Apr 5 at 1:16














      • 2





        Re: loneliness and stress.. What you say is on point, although how people react to that varies, to say the least. My gf didn't want me to attend her thesis, specifically saying that my presence there would stress her even more.. Re: free food - for us there is usually a reception with bubbles, food and beer... so that's always a plus :P

        – posdef
        Apr 3 at 7:31






      • 9





        Re: free food afterwards. It is quite common at my university to have a small snack and a drink right after the defense with your commitee and all the guests, and often you have even more snacks and drinks with your guests, after the commitee left. Essentially, after the defense is over you have a party of sorts.

        – Dohn Joe
        Apr 3 at 8:59






      • 1





        +1, and agree that it varies...perhaps I was too mild because we never ever had more than ~10 people show up to a defense, and for my defense, there was only the committee and one student (even I didn't show up! [was on the phone from thousands of miles away]). I can imagine such a situation being uncomfortable for an undergrad

        – cag51
        Apr 4 at 1:16






      • 5





        +1 for free food!

        – Jakub Konieczny
        Apr 4 at 9:01






      • 1





        Echoing praise for paragraph 3. That's how I felt about it. It helped quite a bit.

        – Randall
        Apr 5 at 1:16








      2




      2





      Re: loneliness and stress.. What you say is on point, although how people react to that varies, to say the least. My gf didn't want me to attend her thesis, specifically saying that my presence there would stress her even more.. Re: free food - for us there is usually a reception with bubbles, food and beer... so that's always a plus :P

      – posdef
      Apr 3 at 7:31





      Re: loneliness and stress.. What you say is on point, although how people react to that varies, to say the least. My gf didn't want me to attend her thesis, specifically saying that my presence there would stress her even more.. Re: free food - for us there is usually a reception with bubbles, food and beer... so that's always a plus :P

      – posdef
      Apr 3 at 7:31




      9




      9





      Re: free food afterwards. It is quite common at my university to have a small snack and a drink right after the defense with your commitee and all the guests, and often you have even more snacks and drinks with your guests, after the commitee left. Essentially, after the defense is over you have a party of sorts.

      – Dohn Joe
      Apr 3 at 8:59





      Re: free food afterwards. It is quite common at my university to have a small snack and a drink right after the defense with your commitee and all the guests, and often you have even more snacks and drinks with your guests, after the commitee left. Essentially, after the defense is over you have a party of sorts.

      – Dohn Joe
      Apr 3 at 8:59




      1




      1





      +1, and agree that it varies...perhaps I was too mild because we never ever had more than ~10 people show up to a defense, and for my defense, there was only the committee and one student (even I didn't show up! [was on the phone from thousands of miles away]). I can imagine such a situation being uncomfortable for an undergrad

      – cag51
      Apr 4 at 1:16





      +1, and agree that it varies...perhaps I was too mild because we never ever had more than ~10 people show up to a defense, and for my defense, there was only the committee and one student (even I didn't show up! [was on the phone from thousands of miles away]). I can imagine such a situation being uncomfortable for an undergrad

      – cag51
      Apr 4 at 1:16




      5




      5





      +1 for free food!

      – Jakub Konieczny
      Apr 4 at 9:01





      +1 for free food!

      – Jakub Konieczny
      Apr 4 at 9:01




      1




      1





      Echoing praise for paragraph 3. That's how I felt about it. It helped quite a bit.

      – Randall
      Apr 5 at 1:16





      Echoing praise for paragraph 3. That's how I felt about it. It helped quite a bit.

      – Randall
      Apr 5 at 1:16











      11














      In the similar situations I know (habilitation kind of dissertations) it will be seen bizarre if you are not there, both on scientific as well as human relationship point of views.






      share|improve this answer




























        11














        In the similar situations I know (habilitation kind of dissertations) it will be seen bizarre if you are not there, both on scientific as well as human relationship point of views.






        share|improve this answer


























          11












          11








          11







          In the similar situations I know (habilitation kind of dissertations) it will be seen bizarre if you are not there, both on scientific as well as human relationship point of views.






          share|improve this answer













          In the similar situations I know (habilitation kind of dissertations) it will be seen bizarre if you are not there, both on scientific as well as human relationship point of views.







          share|improve this answer












          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer










          answered Apr 3 at 10:41









          AlchimistaAlchimista

          41827




          41827























              2














              This is a normal thing to do. I was in a similar position and will be attending my mentor's dissertation in May. It's nice to give back to someone who has helped you out a lot by supporting them during a very challenging experience. Just make sure he's okay with it. He will probably be very encouraged!






              share|improve this answer








              New contributor




              ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
              Check out our Code of Conduct.

























                2














                This is a normal thing to do. I was in a similar position and will be attending my mentor's dissertation in May. It's nice to give back to someone who has helped you out a lot by supporting them during a very challenging experience. Just make sure he's okay with it. He will probably be very encouraged!






                share|improve this answer








                New contributor




                ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                Check out our Code of Conduct.























                  2












                  2








                  2







                  This is a normal thing to do. I was in a similar position and will be attending my mentor's dissertation in May. It's nice to give back to someone who has helped you out a lot by supporting them during a very challenging experience. Just make sure he's okay with it. He will probably be very encouraged!






                  share|improve this answer








                  New contributor




                  ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.










                  This is a normal thing to do. I was in a similar position and will be attending my mentor's dissertation in May. It's nice to give back to someone who has helped you out a lot by supporting them during a very challenging experience. Just make sure he's okay with it. He will probably be very encouraged!







                  share|improve this answer








                  New contributor




                  ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.









                  share|improve this answer



                  share|improve this answer






                  New contributor




                  ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.









                  answered 2 days ago









                  ribs2spareribs2spare

                  211




                  211




                  New contributor




                  ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.





                  New contributor





                  ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.






                  ribs2spare is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
                  Check out our Code of Conduct.























                      1














                      It's fine, I have walked into stressful defence-type lectures which one of my teachers was teaching. I don't mean to put the person off, but it's standard and you have to get used to it. When I first started teaching even though I was nervous I invited my friend to sit in on one of my lectures as it's something you have to get used to. Anyone can walk in there, you could be giving a stressful lecture one day and a family member you haven't seen for ages will randomly walk in and sit down to watch.






                      share|improve this answer



















                      • 5





                        It's not about teaching

                        – George M
                        Apr 3 at 20:49






                      • 2





                        @GeorgeM : No, but it is a similar situation

                        – MPW
                        Apr 3 at 20:55






                      • 8





                        Not at all, but whatever..

                        – George M
                        Apr 3 at 20:56
















                      1














                      It's fine, I have walked into stressful defence-type lectures which one of my teachers was teaching. I don't mean to put the person off, but it's standard and you have to get used to it. When I first started teaching even though I was nervous I invited my friend to sit in on one of my lectures as it's something you have to get used to. Anyone can walk in there, you could be giving a stressful lecture one day and a family member you haven't seen for ages will randomly walk in and sit down to watch.






                      share|improve this answer



















                      • 5





                        It's not about teaching

                        – George M
                        Apr 3 at 20:49






                      • 2





                        @GeorgeM : No, but it is a similar situation

                        – MPW
                        Apr 3 at 20:55






                      • 8





                        Not at all, but whatever..

                        – George M
                        Apr 3 at 20:56














                      1












                      1








                      1







                      It's fine, I have walked into stressful defence-type lectures which one of my teachers was teaching. I don't mean to put the person off, but it's standard and you have to get used to it. When I first started teaching even though I was nervous I invited my friend to sit in on one of my lectures as it's something you have to get used to. Anyone can walk in there, you could be giving a stressful lecture one day and a family member you haven't seen for ages will randomly walk in and sit down to watch.






                      share|improve this answer













                      It's fine, I have walked into stressful defence-type lectures which one of my teachers was teaching. I don't mean to put the person off, but it's standard and you have to get used to it. When I first started teaching even though I was nervous I invited my friend to sit in on one of my lectures as it's something you have to get used to. Anyone can walk in there, you could be giving a stressful lecture one day and a family member you haven't seen for ages will randomly walk in and sit down to watch.







                      share|improve this answer












                      share|improve this answer



                      share|improve this answer










                      answered Apr 3 at 10:42









                      TomTom

                      3466




                      3466








                      • 5





                        It's not about teaching

                        – George M
                        Apr 3 at 20:49






                      • 2





                        @GeorgeM : No, but it is a similar situation

                        – MPW
                        Apr 3 at 20:55






                      • 8





                        Not at all, but whatever..

                        – George M
                        Apr 3 at 20:56














                      • 5





                        It's not about teaching

                        – George M
                        Apr 3 at 20:49






                      • 2





                        @GeorgeM : No, but it is a similar situation

                        – MPW
                        Apr 3 at 20:55






                      • 8





                        Not at all, but whatever..

                        – George M
                        Apr 3 at 20:56








                      5




                      5





                      It's not about teaching

                      – George M
                      Apr 3 at 20:49





                      It's not about teaching

                      – George M
                      Apr 3 at 20:49




                      2




                      2





                      @GeorgeM : No, but it is a similar situation

                      – MPW
                      Apr 3 at 20:55





                      @GeorgeM : No, but it is a similar situation

                      – MPW
                      Apr 3 at 20:55




                      8




                      8





                      Not at all, but whatever..

                      – George M
                      Apr 3 at 20:56





                      Not at all, but whatever..

                      – George M
                      Apr 3 at 20:56










                      Nicole is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.










                      draft saved

                      draft discarded


















                      Nicole is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.













                      Nicole is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.












                      Nicole is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
















                      Thanks for contributing an answer to Academia Stack Exchange!


                      • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                      But avoid



                      • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                      • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                      To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                      draft saved


                      draft discarded














                      StackExchange.ready(
                      function () {
                      StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2facademia.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f127430%2fis-it-inappropriate-for-a-student-to-attend-their-mentors-dissertation-defense%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                      }
                      );

                      Post as a guest















                      Required, but never shown





















































                      Required, but never shown














                      Required, but never shown












                      Required, but never shown







                      Required, but never shown

































                      Required, but never shown














                      Required, but never shown












                      Required, but never shown







                      Required, but never shown







                      Popular posts from this blog

                      Masuk log Menu navigasi

                      Identifying “long and narrow” polygons in with PostGISlength and width of polygonWhy postgis st_overlaps reports Qgis' “avoid intersections” generated polygon as overlapping with others?Adjusting polygons to boundary and filling holesDrawing polygons with fixed area?How to remove spikes in Polygons with PostGISDeleting sliver polygons after difference operation in QGIS?Snapping boundaries in PostGISSplit polygon into parts adding attributes based on underlying polygon in QGISSplitting overlap between polygons and assign to nearest polygon using PostGIS?Expanding polygons and clipping at midpoint?Removing Intersection of Buffers in Same Layers

                      Старые Смолеговицы Содержание История | География | Демография | Достопримечательности | Примечания | НавигацияHGЯOLHGЯOL41 206 832 01641 606 406 141Административно-территориальное деление Ленинградской области«Переписная оброчная книга Водской пятины 1500 года», С. 793«Карта Ингерманландии: Ивангорода, Яма, Копорья, Нотеборга», по материалам 1676 г.«Генеральная карта провинции Ингерманландии» Э. Белинга и А. Андерсина, 1704 г., составлена по материалам 1678 г.«Географический чертёж над Ижорскою землей со своими городами» Адриана Шонбека 1705 г.Новая и достоверная всей Ингерманландии ланткарта. Грав. А. Ростовцев. СПб., 1727 г.Топографическая карта Санкт-Петербургской губернии. 5-и верстка. Шуберт. 1834 г.Описание Санкт-Петербургской губернии по уездам и станамСпецкарта западной части России Ф. Ф. Шуберта. 1844 г.Алфавитный список селений по уездам и станам С.-Петербургской губернииСписки населённых мест Российской Империи, составленные и издаваемые центральным статистическим комитетом министерства внутренних дел. XXXVII. Санкт-Петербургская губерния. По состоянию на 1862 год. СПб. 1864. С. 203Материалы по статистике народного хозяйства в С.-Петербургской губернии. Вып. IX. Частновладельческое хозяйство в Ямбургском уезде. СПб, 1888, С. 146, С. 2, 7, 54Положение о гербе муниципального образования Курское сельское поселениеСправочник истории административно-территориального деления Ленинградской области.Топографическая карта Ленинградской области, квадрат О-35-23-В (Хотыницы), 1930 г.АрхивированоАдминистративно-территориальное деление Ленинградской области. — Л., 1933, С. 27, 198АрхивированоАдминистративно-экономический справочник по Ленинградской области. — Л., 1936, с. 219АрхивированоАдминистративно-территориальное деление Ленинградской области. — Л., 1966, с. 175АрхивированоАдминистративно-территориальное деление Ленинградской области. — Лениздат, 1973, С. 180АрхивированоАдминистративно-территориальное деление Ленинградской области. — Лениздат, 1990, ISBN 5-289-00612-5, С. 38АрхивированоАдминистративно-территориальное деление Ленинградской области. — СПб., 2007, с. 60АрхивированоКоряков Юрий База данных «Этно-языковой состав населённых пунктов России». Ленинградская область.Административно-территориальное деление Ленинградской области. — СПб, 1997, ISBN 5-86153-055-6, С. 41АрхивированоКультовый комплекс Старые Смолеговицы // Электронная энциклопедия ЭрмитажаПроблемы выявления, изучения и сохранения культовых комплексов с каменными крестами: по материалам работ 2016-2017 гг. в Ленинградской области